Showing posts with label Iraq War Inquiry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iraq War Inquiry. Show all posts

24/06/2009

Brown backs down on Iraq inquiry

Following indications last week that the Government looked set for a u-turn on whether or not to hold the Iraq War inquiry in public, PM Gordon Brown has given what may well be taken as the most reliable sign so far that they'll opt for transparency when he said that he would be willing to give evidence publically.

The UK Government's decision to go to war in Iraq received widespread criticism.
Copyright-free image from Wikipedia.

Original plans to carry out and hear the findings into the controversial war - described by LibDem leader Nick Clegg as "probably the biggest foreign policy mistake that any government has made since Suez" and widely attacked by the British public - in private attracted almost universal condemnation amongst the media and voters - opinions were not improved by the fact that the story made news at the same time as the row over how much information related to MPs' expenses and whether or not Shahid Malik's return to the Cabinet should and would be published. Still aching from his party's embarrassing performance at the elections earlier this month and desperate to improve Labour's standing amongst the electorate, Mr. Brown quickly bowed before popular feeling and allowed both to be made public, albeit it in heavily-censored form in the case of the former.

Keeping the inquiry under wraps was criticised by MPs too, with
Gordon Prentice (Pendle) saying he was "not prepared to accept a secret inquiry into Iraq." The families of servicemen killed during the conflict were also against the plan, as were senior military officers.

"If those considerations concerning national security our met, then of course the Prime Minister would have no difficulty in giving evidence in public," a No.10 spokesperson has said - even though he looked distinctly unkeen on doing so not too long ago. That Mr. Brown has finally learned to listen to the country is to be celebrated, but it really looks too little far too late: these are the final, desperate struggles of a politician, a government and a party as they reach the end of their lives (though we hope "life" will only apply metaphorically in Gordon's case, of course, he may be an awful PM but we don't wish death on him. Uncomfortable and embarrassing illness, perhaps, but not death).

Let's just hope that, when and if Labour goes down in flames, a new party rises from its ashes and it has the red plumage of the organisation in its pre-Blair days rather than the blue-tinted (and rather bedraggled, currently) feathers of New Labour - no matter what your politics, it is important to have a viable opposition to keep the ruling party in check and unless Labour can pull off a miracle very soon, the Conservatives will entirely dominate Parliament following the next General Election.

18/06/2009

Iraq Inquiry to be public?

Following anger expressed by both opposition parties and campaigners - and just before a possible defeat at the hands of back-benchers next week, something the Cabinet could do without so soon after their recent embarrassments - Prime Minister Gordon Brown has changed his mind over the forthcoming inquiry into the Iraq War and it looks set to be published openly.

Mr. Brown's smile has not been a common sight in recent weeks. Image adapted from one at Wikipedia, used in accordance with Creative Commons ShareAlike2.0 license.

Although Defence Minister David Miliband has stated that all but the most sensitive details would be made available, Tory leader David Cameron accused Labour of "an establishment stitch-up." LibDem MPs said they were planning to boycott the inquiry altogether. Mr. Brown faced further attacks from his own party, with Ed Balls saying that he would "prefer it to be as open as possible" and Gordon Prentice (Pendle) saying he was "not prepared to accept a secret inquiry into Iraq." Families of servicemen killed in the conflict have also condemned the decision; Rose Gentle, the mother of Gordon Gentle who was killed by a roadside bomb in 2004 after just six months' military training, says "we have fought and fought for this but it will be no use and it could all be for nothing behind closed doors" and adding that she and others would continue in their efforts to have the inquiry made public.

The inquiry is scheduled to begin next month and is expected to take more than a year to reach a conclusion about the war and the controversial decisions that led to Britain joining it, which LibDem leader Nick Clegg has called "probably the biggest foreign policy mistake that any government has made since Suez."

Mr. Brown has faced increasing demands for greater transparency recently following the MPs' expenses scandal, which led to the investigation into claims made by Dewsbury MP Shahid Malik - which was originally going to be kept secret - becoming a thorn in the PM's side as he was forced to publicise it in order for the electorate to be certain nothing was being kept quiet and nothing untoward was taking place. A No.10 spokesperson has claimed that it was never an "issue of theology" as to whether or not the inquiry would be made publically available - however, earlier statements that he needed to take into account national security and the worldwide reputation of British military are thought by many to be coded excuses for excess secrecy since nobody expects anything other than a version in which confidential data of this type will have been edited out. We'll all just have to make our minds up over whether or not this secrecy was indeed excessive and why it may have been thought necessary, since all we can be certain of is that if there is some information revealing that the war should not have taken place it'll have been removed before we get a chance to see it.

Lord Mandelson - who for all his many faults is perhaps the finest political tactician Parliament has seen in many years (which is why he's still around despite his career having seemingly come to an end on many occasions) - recently made a few suggestions that he felt Mr. Brown needed to take on board if he is to survive as Labour leader. One of these was that the PM needed to start "listening to people," in order to rid himself of his reputation for riding rough-shod over other people's opinions. Could it be that his party's disastrous election results the week before last were enough to make Gordon see sense in Mandelson's advice and decide he'll pay a bit of attention to popular opinion in the future? Stranger things have happened.